Site Meter
Send Us An Email
Panama Guide

Welcome to Panama Guide
Thursday, August 21 2014 @ 12:19 AM EDT

The Conduct Of The Police Officers Was "Criminal"

Crime & Punishment The two National Police officers accused of giving a beating on September 22, 2011 to Rafael Perez Carillo nephrologist at a police checkpoint in El Carmen, Bella Vista, committed unlawful conduct; they attacked him even though he was outnumbered and had already been neutralized. This was stated by the Eighth Circuit Prosecutor Dania Rios in the conclusions of the investigation in this case that was sent to the Judiciary on 28 May 2012, with a request for a trial against Police Sergeant Ferdín González and police officer Miguel Rivera, who are accused of negligent personal injury.

According to the Prosecutor Rios, nothing Perez Carillo said that night justified the aggression against him. In his complaint, the doctor when he arrived at the checkpoint he told the police officer Rivera he was a doctor, and he needed to pass through the checkpoint quickly, in the same way as the other three cars that had just passed through before him, because he was in a hurry to pick up his children. However, Rivera said the cars had been passed through previously had escorts.

Then Police Sergeant Gonzalez approached him, Perez Carillo's driver's license, and told him to park the car. When Perez Carillo exited the car, Gonzalez walked toward him with his hand on his service weapon, and he immediately sprayed him with pepper spray. Perez Carillo admitted he tried to defend himself, but Police Officer Rivera threw him to the ground, handcuffed him, and put his knee in his back. There, once on the ground and dominated, Police Sergeant González kicked him in the face and sprayed him with pepper spray again. Then other police officers arrived on the scene, they surrounded him and put him in a police patrol car.

When Perez Carillo's wife appeared on the scene, the police officers finally took him to the hospital, handcuffed in the back of the patrol car.

His Injuries Coincide - In an affidavit, Police Officer John Cruz said Doctor Perez Carillo resisted arrest and became aggressive, so Rivera struggled with him in order to arrest him, and he hit his face on the floor as they tried to control him. However, the expert report from the Office of Legal Medicine indicates Perez Carillo had a hematoma and hemorrhage in the right eye, bruising and right nasal septum deviation, a hematoma on the upper lip, and scrapes on his left elbow and knee. According to the forensic investigators, the doctor's injuries are consistent with his complaint.

On the other hand, there are no documents in the official case file from the Directorate of Professional Responsibility of the National Police about the internal disciplinary process both Police Sergeant Gonzalez and Police Officer Rivera should have faced, because the National Police failed to send those documents to the Public Ministry, even through the Prosecutors requested officially them as part of their investigations. Mara Rivera, the Official Spokeswoman for the National Police, said the institution has confidence in the decisions of the authorities, and they will not comment on the process.

When they were questioned, both Sergeant Gonzalez and Officer Rivera took advantage of Article 25 of the Constitution, and remained silent.

Precedent - Meanwhile, Perez Carillo said he hopes justice will be served, and an exemplary punishment is applied to the two policemen. He said he hopes this case will set a precedent so that no one else is abused in this manner. His lawyer José Broce said no one is safe in Panama when they are detained by the National Police, because, as he warns, abuses are rampant, but almost no one files and official complaint. He said people should call a family member as soon as possible if they are being arrested.

The preliminary hearing was set by the Fifteenth Criminal Court for Thursday, 26 July 2012. Both Sergeant Gonzalez and Officer Rivera have been prevented from leaving the country, and they continue to work on the streets in their jobs.

The Sergeant Is A Repeat Offender In Personal Injuries - The Official Police Record of Sergeant Ferdín González, a copy of which resides in the archives of the Directorate of Judicial Investigation (DIJ) to which this newspaper (La Prensa) had access, contains 19 administrative and criminal proceedings. According to this document, Gonzalez is a repeat offender and he has at least four convictions for the crime of injury.

In 1974, the Mayor of Pesé sentenced him to 25 days in jail for breaking the roof tiles of a residence. The following year (1975) he served eight months in prison, sentenced by the Second Circuit Court of Herrera, for the crime of injury. In 1976 he served 9 months and 10 days in prison for the same offense, to the detriment of Arcenio Polo Hernandez. What's more, the Second Criminal Court of Los Santos sentenced him to 16 months and 5 days in prison for personal injuries against Arturo Perez. The Second Criminal Court of Chitre sentenced him to 30 months in prison for the same crime in 1982. In other cases he was convicted for fights and scandals, for carrying an illegal knife, and for insulting members of the National Guard in 1982.

Rivera has no criminal record. (Prensa)

Editor's Comment: Wow. Talk about the classic "bad apple." It's pretty clear this Gonzalez guy is one fucked-up, violent asshole. If the contents of this article are correct and accurate, then there's no way this guy should be serving in the National Police. I think it's a disgusting bit of bullshit the National Police have failed to provide documentation on any sort of internal disciplinary action taken against Gonzalez and Rivera. Why didn't they? Because - simply enough - they didn't do a damn thing against these guys. I believe the doctor. I think they threw him to the ground, handcuffed him, pepper sprayed him, and repeatedly kicked him in the face. In other words - Police Sergeant Gonzalez is a Sadistic Fuck who should spend some more time in prison, and then be summarily fired from the National Police in disgrace with no sort of reward or pension whatsoever. I think the younger officer Rivera was probably influenced by the much older Sergeant Gonzalez who was his superior officer on the scene that night. He should probably be punished and reprimanded, but the real bad guy here seems to be Gonzalez. Let's see what the court does in this case. On another note, the National Police need to wake the hell up and purge this sort of cancer from their ranks. It makes no sense whatsoever to protect this sort of vile, evil, sadistic, violent, and dangerous person.

  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks

Story Options

The Conduct Of The Police Officers Was "Criminal" | 4 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
The Conduct Of The Police Officers Was \"Criminal\"
Authored by: Anonymous on Monday, July 23 2012 @ 12:13 PM EDT

Ok, this police officer has a history, and he probably didn't hesitated long to apply violence. However, it's interesting that these stories mostly happen with doctors. I'm not surprised, they somehow think they are more important than normal people.. He can't be stopped by the police because he has to pick up his kids? And then he probably started to insult the officers and resisted arrest, I can kinda see what happened there...

The Conduct Of The Police Officers Was \"Criminal\"
Authored by: Anonymous on Monday, July 23 2012 @ 02:42 PM EDT

Woah! Another glaring example of the Pana police state in keeps getting worse. Its always been borderline at best, but now its just getting rediculous.....bad for bizniss.....was on my way to surf the river mouth at Estero Rico here in Chiriqui with a Pana buddy and we ran into a roadblock like this and I had a close encounter with one bulldog power tripper in uniform........I just dont see any reason for stopping every friggin car on the road that is passing thru some small town in the middle of nowhere to check all the documents like the old Soviet Union.....a few minutes ago I was speaking with a friend/assoc in San Jose and I pointed it out to him and he read it while we were online, and was just astonished. And I asked him when was the last time he could remember something likethat happening in C.R. He couldnt.......unless maybe it was the homeless crackheads in redzones of the city........somethings gotta change here, and fast, cuz words gettin out. Everybody around here is talkin about it.....were all afaid to drink a few beers and then drive home to the country.......cuz theyre more than likely out there waiting for you. And you dont have to be doing anything wrong to get stopped and scrutinized and have your time wasted.........meanwhile, the bad guys are gettin away....................................

The Conduct Of The Police Officers Was \"Criminal\"
Authored by: Anonymous on Monday, July 23 2012 @ 05:20 PM EDT

Well, at least they apply equal brutality to everyone, rich and poor. Her in U.S.A, it is only applied to the poor.

The Conduct Of The Police Officers Was \"Criminal\"
Authored by: Anonymous on Tuesday, July 24 2012 @ 02:26 PM EDT

I am reading the article and the responses here. I dont know what this man said to these cops,but it appears that words and possibly more occured,there are 2 sides to the story we all know.
I have spent years here in panama and I have to say,not siding without the full story,but I have never felt threatened,in danger or in any other then "hola,como esta" and conversation or maybe show my papers or something like that with the police from panama to the frontera.
I actually cant believe how laid back and friendly they have been to me and actually saved me one time when I almost drove at night into los chorillos.
I do exerpt the police in bocas del toro,"sorry guys"
It seems that this man wanted to pass a check point at his own speed and became aggrivated with the police and maybe big headed because he is a doctor,I did not read the doctor was heading to an emergency.
and believe me,if the police are doing their job,maybe stopping criminals,checking illegals papers or something like that, I dont want to rush them and I respect them.
Sorry for this guys experience but ,in the states you try to force your way through a road block,your gonna be taseredor something like that.
I give them respect and a smile and they give it right back.
Take care again,sorry for your experience.